Eragon Inheritance Series (Author: Christopher Paolini): book review

76

By SimeyC

Pre-order inheritance for delivery on 11/11/11

Inheritance Cycle Omnibus: Eragon, Eldest, and Brisingr
Amazon Price: $38.93

Eragon Inheritance Series review

When Eragon finds a mysterious stone in the mountains, he doesn’t realize the trouble that it is going to cause him. The stone happens to be a Dragon’s egg and much to Eragon’s surprise, the stone hatches and becomes a young dragon named Saphira – he is even more shocked when he finds out that he can communicate with Saphira!

Once Kill Galbatorix learns of the birth of the dragon, and of Eragan he sends his evil minions to Eragon’s village and destroy the farm that Eragon lives on. Fleeing for his life with Saphira, Eragon is initially mentored by Brom, an enigmatic man from the village, and eventually ends up searching for the mysterious Varden who seek to destroy Galbatorix…..

Eragon is a pretty standard fantasy series that has most of the major elements that similar fantasy novels have; dragons, magicians, evil enemies, love, war and danger. Christopher Paolini has drawn on influences such as Tolkien, Edison and Pullman and really doesn’t provide anything new to the fantasy genre.

Having said that, the series is well written, with some decent characters, a decent and exciting plot and some intriguing mysticism; Paolini does have the ability of creating a story that drags you in, and his strength is perhaps the way in which he has the ability to describe the scenery and really make it come to life.

The pace of the books is excellent and generally, aside from a few parts, the story moves along nicely and you don’t find yourself getting bored, or getting inundated with too much ‘facts’ that would otherwise drag the story down.

The lack of originality aside, this is one of the better fantasy series available, and perhaps is a great introduction to the genre for teens; it’s not as daunting to read as Lord of the Rings, but is very easy to read and finish. It’s not one of those books that you won’t be able to put down, but it is interesting and the plot is good enough to make you want to finish it. It should also be noted that some of the best fantasy series around today (Sword of Shannara, Wheel of Time series) are all heavily influenced by Tolkien, and have many similarities, so Paolini isn’t the first to do this.

Paolini is a very young author – he was only fifteen at the time he wrote the first book in the series, so there’s no doubt in my mind that as he grows older, and really begins to work on his craft, that we will begin to see originality in his writings – it’ll therefore be interesting to be able to step back and take a look at his earlier work and compare.

As I said, this series is a good series; some fantasy fans won’t enjoy it because they see it as a rip-off of Tolkien, but this shouldn’t detract readers from trying out the series.

Silver Poet profile image

Silver Poet Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

Thanks for the review. I liked the movie and was disappointed they didn't make a sequel.

satomko profile image

satomko Level 1 Commenter 2 years ago

I think the series is okay for people who are getting started on high fantasy literature, but put me in the camp that felt pretty much everything about Eragon felt too familiar. I think if you've read a bit of fantasy already, then you'll be able to predict pretty much everything that happens in the book. It's not bad, but it feels redundant.

SimeyC profile image

SimeyC Hub Author 2 years ago

Satomko: exactly - it's a good introduction to the Genre. Paolini is still young so I expect he'll write some decent non predictable stuff eventually...

M. T. Dremer profile image

M. T. Dremer Level 4 Commenter 2 years ago

I really enjoyed the first two books in the series. (Eragon and Eldest). They used some of the genre's cliches but they were fun to read. However, I got extremely frustrated with the third book (Brisingr). It was painfully slow moving; the story wandered about chapter after chapter, and the characters seemed to betray their earlier portrayals (Roran specifically, who went from small town hero to something god-like for no apparent reason). Then when I discovered that he was writing a fourth, I was shouting "Hey! You could have fit all the material in Brisingr if you'd just edited out all the pointless stuff". But despite this frustration I have, I would still recommend the series. In fact, I'm going to get it for my nephew on his birthday. I just wish Christopher Paolini would work a little harder on his editing.

SimeyC profile image

SimeyC Hub Author 2 years ago

M T Dremer: it's a great introduction to fantasy and defintaley worth a read for your Nephew! A couple of points - Paolini did actually mean to write one book, but it wouild have been a very very large volume so he split in two - probably why it is so disjointed. Paolini is very young and still learning the trade - this series may be re-edited over time, but I expect his future writing to get a lot better!!!

sarah0330 profile image

sarah0330 13 months ago

Ouch! I really felt bad reading the comments here. I am a huge fan of the Inheritance cycle. But I still respect your opinions. I started reading it after watching the movie Eragon and I was drawn to the story immediately. I recommended it to my friends and they too loved it. I do read a lot of fantasy and for me, it's one of the best I've seen. And I'm looking forward to the final book. :)

Zach LaGreca 6 months ago

I've been a heavy reader in the fantasy genre since I was a kid, and honestly Eragon is my favorite fantasy series behind Lord of the Rings. Yes it's predictable, yes it's cliche, yes many of the elements have been done before. But in my opinion it is one of the best renditions of "The Heroes Journey" archetype. My personal reasons for this opinion: he takes my favorite elements from the genre (everything I loved from Tolkien, U.K. Leguin, McCaffrey, Brooks, etc) and put new characters to them.

Sure, the characters and events are cliche, but there's something about this cliche, this heroes journey and growth from boy to man, that resonates with me. And many other young ones. I read Eragon when I was 13. Many of the feelings Eragon has struck a chord with me - and I think it was due to the fact that Paolini was at that stage in life as he wrote. The stories grow with Paolini and the readers.

Predictable as it may be, it's still one of the more inspiring I've ever enjoyed. And no doubt his future works will show some more originality and flexibility.

SimeyC profile image

SimeyC Hub Author 6 months ago

Zach: I do think he is an excellent writer who will writer exceptional fantasies in the future! I guess the problem for me is that he played it safe - and I feel he's a lot more talented than that - I read a book by Brandon Sanderson recently, another fairly new writer and his work was amazing! I say it again though, he is a very young writer and will be a master one day!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working